If I had to pick one white varietal to drink for the rest of my life, it would probably be Riesling. Why? Well, for starters, in my experience it is the most terroir-expressive white wine grape. Terroir is a dicey French word; dicey because it does not have a direct translation in English. The best definition I have heard is that terroir is anything that’s outside the control of the winegrower and winemaker. Friends of terroir are soil, weather, and geography. Enemies of terroir include over-oaking and over-ripening. Further, Riesling makes delicious wines in a number of different styles, from dry to sweet. Riesling is able to make sweet wines that are not cloying due to its high natural acidity.
Riesling is the most common grape varietal in Germany and in the Alsace region of France. These two areas tend to produce the Rieslings with the most renown and ageworthiness. Reading German wine labels can be tricky. I have found this Wikipedia article to be a good resource for decoding the difference between kabinett, spatlese, auslese, and all the other iterations.
While we waited for everyone to arrive, we had a cocktail of 2006 Chateau Ste. Michelle & Dr. Loosen Riesling Eroica – $24 @ QFC. CSM makes a number of different Rieslings, and this is their highest-end version that is not a dessert wine.
Rating: 3. Lovely nose of creamed figs that reminded me more of Semillon than of Riesling. On the palate, juicy pineapple flavors and huge acidity that for me ventured into the realm of tartness. Nice, long finish.
Then it was onto the blind tasting, where we tried 4 Washington Rieslings and 1 German:
2007 Charles Smith Wines Riesling Kung Fu Girl – $13 @ QFC
Rating: 3. Muted nose that, with vigorous swirling, revealed hints of candied pineapple. On the palate, screaming pink grapefruit on the attack and in the middle, followed by a green apple finish. Lots of bright, tart acidity.
2006 OS Winery Riesling Champoux Vineyard – $20 @ QFC.
Rating: NR. This nose smelled like I just pulled into a gas station; all rubber and gasoline. As I read up on Riesling, I found that petrol notes are actually considered a sign of quality and ageworthiness by some, but I found it off-putting. By far the most restrained palate of the night, with some fig and herbal notes coming through.
2007 Long Shadows Wineries Riesling Poet’s Leap – $20 @ Metropolitan Market
Rating: 3. The most tropical nose of the bunch. This smelled like a mango lassi, with hints of canned peaches and marshmallows as the night went on. The palate was rich with pineapple and orange, and the finish was spicy. This was tasty, linear (quick definition: linear wines bring consistent flavors across the beginning, middle, and finish of your palate), and uncomplicated.
2007 Chateau Ste. Michelle Riesling Cold Creek Vineyard – $13 @ QFC
Rating: 4. Completely different aromas than the bottles I tasted over the summer. No fruit on the nose; instead entrancing saline aromas that reminded me of the Jersey shore – some combination of seashells, jetty rocks, and salty air. The palate, on the other hand, was full of rich, generous, delicious fruit (pear and citrus) and gorgeous acidity. This was the wine of the night for me and remains a steal at $13.
2007 Mönchhof Robert Eymael Ürziger Würzgarten Riesling Kabinett – $21 @ McCarthy & Schiering
Rating: 4. Wow – huge, floral nose on this wine; smells like an orange blossom overflowing with nectar. On the palate, the most notable element for me was the acid, which was absolutely perfect. It gave a brightness to the grapefruit and floral flavors that I loved. This also had a long, intriguing finish of green melon.
Some of my readers were at this tasting, and I invite them to add their thoughts or tasting notes as comments.
Recent Comments